CIO ADVISORY

IT Sourcing

4C helps CIOs to reassess their scope of services, delivery model and provider landscape. We clarify which capabilities should remain in-house, which services should be outsourced, and how AI is changing costs, remuneration and provider management.

SOURCING AS A MANAGEMENT DECISION

Established sourcing models often no longer meet today’s requirements.

Contracts, provider structures and delivery locations evolve over many years. At the same time, cloud, SaaS, AI, regulatory requirements and shortages of specialist skills are changing how IT services can be delivered. Simply carrying the existing scope forward at renewal also preserves the old delivery model.

Before a contract is awarded, organisations need to decide which services to deliver themselves, which capabilities to retain in-house and which services are best sourced from partners. Bringing services back in-house also requires a clear target model and a realistic plan for knowledge transfer.

4C works with CIOs and Procurement to prepare these decisions. On legal matters, we work closely with your internal or external legal advisers.

Assess your sourcing position

TYPICAL TRIGGERS

When to reassess your sourcing model

Action is needed when existing contracts or provider structures no longer reflect service requirements, internal capabilities or the organisation’s risk profile.

01

A major contract is approaching expiry.

Before renewing or retendering, the organisation needs to determine whether the service scope, delivery model and provider structure are still appropriate.

02

Providers are using AI, but pricing has yet to reflect it.

Automation changes delivery effort and productivity. CIOs need to establish how these effects should be reflected in the business case and pricing model.

03

Critical knowledge, data or access rights sit with the provider.

The organisation lacks the internal knowledge or access needed to assess or commission changes effectively. Switching providers would require substantial knowledge transfer.

04

The provider landscape has expanded, but governance has not kept pace.

Different SLA and KPI frameworks make it difficult to establish a consistent view of performance, costs and risks.

05

Capabilities and capacity no longer match future demand.

New platforms, major transformation programmes, reorganisations and M&A change which capabilities need to be retained in-house and which services should be sourced externally.

06

Third-party risk and resilience require demonstrable controls.

For organisations within scope, NIS2 raises requirements for supply chain security and business continuity. In the financial sector, DORA additionally requires documented and regularly reviewed exit strategies for ICT services supporting critical or important functions.

CIO · PROCUREMENT · LEGAL

Service delivery, pricing and contractual requirements need to align.

A pricing model only works when the service scope and performance measures are clear. An exit clause is of limited value if data, knowledge transfer and transition have not been addressed. That is why we link sourcing design with commercial considerations and involve Legal at an early stage.

CIO

Service scope & delivery model

Define the scope of in-house delivery, architectural dependencies, resilience and governance requirements.

Procurement

Tendering & pricing

Align the provider portfolio, tendering process, evaluation criteria and pricing models with the target model.

Legal

Contractual requirements

Address liability, data-related obligations, audit and exit rights, and regulatory requirements in the contractual arrangements. Legal drafting and review are carried out by your internal or external legal advisers.

KEY DECISIONS

The decisions that need to be made now

  1. 01 IN-HOUSE CAPABILITIES

    Which services must the organisation retain the capability to manage in-house, and which can be delivered externally?

  2. 02 DELIVERY & RIGHT-SHORING

    What combination of internal teams, providers and onshore, nearshore and offshore delivery is appropriate for each service?

  3. 03 COST EFFICIENCY & AI PRODUCTIVITY GAINS

    How do automation and AI change delivery effort, total cost of ownership (TCO) and the sharing of productivity gains?

  4. 04 PROVIDER GOVERNANCE

    Which KPI and SLA principles should apply across all providers, independently of individual vendors’ governance models?

  5. 05 RESILIENCE & EXIT

    Which dependencies are acceptable, and which capabilities, data, access rights and alternatives must be secured to enable a transition?

  6. 06 TENDERING & CONTRACTUAL REQUIREMENTS

    Which service, pricing and contractual requirements must be defined before a tender or renewal?

OUR SERVICES

Define the future service delivery model

Decisions are made for each service or service area. 4C assesses which services can sensibly be sourced externally, which capabilities must remain in-house, the appropriate delivery model and the associated costs and dependencies.

01

Sourcing strategy & target model

Define the scope of in-house delivery for each service and identify the capabilities the organisation needs to retain.

Typical components
  • Service and capability sourcing matrix
  • Make-or-buy decisions and potential insourcing by service area
  • Assessment of business criticality, constraints and market availability
  • Retained capabilities and responsibilities
02

Delivery model & right-shoring

Combine internal teams, providers and delivery locations to achieve the right balance of service performance, capabilities and risk.

Typical components
  • Internal teams, external specialists and managed services
  • Onshore, nearshore and offshore options
  • Service boundaries, interfaces and provider roles
  • Integration of cloud and SaaS services into the delivery model
03

Cost efficiency & AI productivity gains

Make TCO and productivity assumptions transparent and determine how efficiency gains should be reflected in commercial arrangements.

Typical components
  • Scenario-based business case and TCO for each option
  • Provider costs and internal costs
  • Transition, parallel operations and required capability development
  • Productivity assumptions relating to automation and AI
04

Tendering, pricing & contractual requirements

Align the tendering process and commercial negotiations with the chosen sourcing model.

Typical components
  • Service specifications and evaluation criteria
  • Capacity-, usage-, transaction- and outcome-based pricing models
  • Requirements for SLAs, change management, price reviews and exit
  • Support with provider selection and commercial negotiations

4C brings experience at the interface between service delivery, pricing and contractual requirements. Legal drafting and review are undertaken by your internal or external legal advisers, working closely with 4C.

05

Resilience, third-party risk & exit

Identify critical dependencies and exit options before entering into new commitments.

Typical components
  • Provider and concentration risks
  • Knowledge, data, access rights and available alternatives
  • Business continuity, transition and exit scenarios
  • Relevant requirements under DORA and NIS2, coordinated with Legal, Security and Compliance
06

Cross-provider governance model

Define a consistent governance framework across different providers.

Typical components
  • Provider roles and end-to-end responsibilities
  • Common KPI and SLA principles and targets
  • Consistent escalation and decision-making processes
  • A shared data foundation and management reporting across providers
  • Assessment of how AI can analyse heterogeneous provider data and support governance

Clarification: Ongoing operational provider governance falls within Provider Management. In IT Sourcing, we design the future governance model.

Governance should follow the client’s rules, not the models of individual providers.

Consistent KPI and SLA principles make performance comparable across providers and reduce dependencies on individual contract and governance models.

AI, PRICING & CONTRACTS

When AI changes delivery effort, pricing models need to be reassessed.

Many IT services are still priced on an FTE or time-and-materials basis. If AI reduces a provider's delivery effort, this does not automatically result in a financial benefit for the client. What matters is which services have been agreed, how productivity is measured and which adjustment mechanisms are in place.

Pricing basis by service

Capacity, usage, transactions or outcomes: the right pricing basis depends on the service concerned.

Make productivity assumptions transparent

Expected benefits from automation and AI should be reflected in the business case, including the baseline, prerequisites and measurement approach.

Adjustments during the contract term

Technology and pricing reviews can help reassess service delivery and pricing when material changes occur.

Address data and exit requirements early

For AI-enabled services, data access, documentation, model dependencies and exit requirements need to be considered early and properly addressed in the contractual arrangements.

OUR APPROACH

From the current position to a sourcing decision

01 SCOPE

Work with the CIO and Procurement to define the services in scope, the decision to be made and the applicable criteria. Involve Legal wherever contractual or regulatory matters are relevant.

02 ASSESSMENT

Assess future service requirements, internal capabilities, provider dependencies, costs and risks.

03 OPTIONS

Develop clearly comparable options for delivery models, locations and provider roles for each service.

04 DECISION

Compare TCO, quality, resilience and dependencies, alongside implications for pricing, contracts and exit.

05 TRANSITION

Consolidate the recommendation and document what needs to be prepared ahead of tendering, a provider change or insourcing. Tender documentation and evaluation criteria can be agreed as additional deliverables.

OUTCOMES

What will have been decided

Scope of in-house delivery

For every service in scope, there is a clear decision on who will deliver it and which capabilities and responsibilities will remain in-house.

Delivery and provider model

Delivery locations, provider roles and interfaces are defined, and critical dependencies are visible.

Cost efficiency and pricing

TCO, key assumptions and the intended pricing model are transparent. The business case reflects the impact of automation and AI.

Governance, resilience and exit

The cross-provider governance framework is defined. Requirements for business continuity, data, provider transition and exit are clarified before tendering.

Typical decision-making deliverables

  • Service/capability sourcing matrix
  • Sourcing target model
  • Scenario-based business case
  • Provider portfolio
  • Tendering and evaluation framework
  • Governance and exit framework

EXPERIENCE & EVIDENCE

IT sourcing experience and research

01 Best Management Consultants 2026 brand eins / Statista · IT Strategy
What this means

Recognition in the IT strategy consulting category.

02 More than 20 years IT Strategy & Transformation
What this means

Extensive consulting experience in IT strategy, organisation and business-critical transformation programmes.

03 33 IT executives · 13 industries 4C research on IT organisation & sourcing
What this means

Research into IT organisation, sourcing and international delivery models.

04 IT Sourcing Analysis 4C’s service-by-service approach
What this means

Assessment of sourcing suitability, the sourcing mix and the target model for each service or service area.

RESEARCH · AI IN IT SOURCING 2027

AI is changing service delivery, pricing and contracts in IT sourcing.

4C is currently researching how AI is changing the delivery of services by providers, pricing models, contractual requirements and provider governance. The findings will be published in 2027.

4C STUDY AI in
IT Sourcing
2027
Publication in 2027
Study in preparation

Experts

Talk to our IT Sourcing experts

Martin Stephany

Senior Partner

Martin Stephany

Industrial Engineer (KIT)

Strategy and transformation projects in Digital Technology & Infrastructure

Lars Heuer

Associate Partner

Lars Heuer

Graduate in Physics

IT sourcing strategy, contract negotiations & provider management

Benjamin Juntermanns

Principal

Benjamin Juntermanns

Master of Science - MS, Management

IT Strategy, Operating Model & Digital Transformation

FAQ

Frequently asked questions about IT sourcing

Are tendering and commercial negotiations part of the advisory service?

Yes, if required. Our core service is to support decisions on how IT services should be delivered in future. Tender documentation, evaluation criteria, provider selection and commercial negotiations can be included as additional services. Procurement procedures and legal approvals remain the responsibility of your organisation.

What role does 4C play in contractual matters?

4C translates the sourcing target model into functional and commercial requirements for service delivery, SLAs, pricing, contract adjustments and exit. Legal drafting and review are carried out by your internal or external legal advisers. 4C works closely with Legal at this interface.

How does IT Sourcing differ from an IT Target Operating Model?

IT Sourcing determines how and by whom defined services will be delivered in future. The IT Target Operating Model covers the IT organisation as a whole, including roles, decision-making authority, governance and collaboration between IT and the business.

When is Provider Management the more suitable service?

In IT Sourcing, we design the future provider and governance model. Once this model is broadly established, ongoing management and improvement of performance, costs, SLAs and escalations fall within Provider Management.

How do you take automation and AI into account?

We assess how automation and AI change service scope, capacity requirements, TCO and pricing models. For AI-enabled services, we also consider dependencies relating to data, models and exit options. Technical AI implementation is not part of this service.

Does 4C handle technical implementation?

No. 4C prepares management decisions and can support tendering, transition and organisational governance. Technical migration, implementation and operations remain the responsibility of your internal teams or appointed technology and service partners.

CIO ADVISORY

Which sourcing decision are you facing?

Whether you are considering a contract renewal, a new delivery model, AI in your provider landscape or an exit strategy, we clarify which decisions need to be prepared and where 4C can provide support.

Discuss your sourcing model

Recognised

Best Management Consultants 2026

Recognized by our clients and partners

brand eins Thema Beste Unternehmensberater 2026

Your non-binding enquiry

We appreciate your message and will get back to you promptly. You can find information about data processing in our data protection notice.

Submit a non-binding inquiry
Contact us for a non-binding discussion and tell us about your concerns.